The ticking time bomb scenario is a thought experiment that has been used in the ethics debate over whether torture can ever be justified as a thought experiment, there is no need that the scenario be plausible it need only serve to highlight ethical considerations. Whether or nor torture can ever be justified is one of the most heated debates raging amongst the academia and the intelligentsia nowadays especially with respect to interrogation practices used by the united states. Not only do 59 percent of americans say the torture of suspected terrorists was justified, but 58 percent say torture is often or sometimes justified, as a general matter jamelle bouie.
Torture can be defined as, ‘the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty’(dershowitz, a) according to international law, it is illegal to use torture in any situation of any kind. Many claim that torture can be justified because it comes down to the safety of the people they believe that torturing someone in order to gain information that could potentially save lives is acceptable or even reasonable, however, this is not the case. Essays ‘torture can be justified if it serves the greater good’ critically discuss this statement with reference to human rights theories ‘torture can be justified if it serves the greater good’ critically discuss this statement with reference to human rights theories. Essay about the morality of torture torture is a controversial topic in today’s society what is torture torture can be defined as, ‘the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty’(dershowitz, a) according to international law, it is illegal to use torture in any situation of any kind.
The scenario the 'ticking bomb' problem the problem that even the most virtuous people face when thinking about torture is whether there is ever a case when a good result produced by torture. It disputes the general acceptance by both that if the stakes are high enough, torture can be justified on consequentialist grounds it concludes that the debate about whether torture is permissible is conducted within a narrow narrative framework which both obscures the purpose of torture and sets up false and misleading choices between. Torture can be justified (but not always) when you know that a person is part of a plan to harm others, is able to prevent the harm by giving you information, but refuses to do so so clearly you should not torture simple soldiers in a regular war and you should honor international conventions about war. Is torture ever justified in a post-9/11 world frontline gathered a group of legal thinkers to answer this question several of them had studied the torture question together for a joint project.
It is the author’s opinion that torture can never be justified and can never be considered the ethically correct thing to do there is no ethical theory offered in this paper that the author subscribes to that can correctly be applied to any of the justifications offered in the two case studies used. In the case of extreme circumstances on the condition that it is accompanied by a valid judicial warrant, dershowitz believes that torture can be necessary this was the beginning of a massive change in the thought process of torture. Is the use torture ever justified essay sample according time in the follow asian, middle east and other countries have used torture as a tool of murder for over two thousand years. ” torture is not acceptable because it is degrading and ethically wrong, but under certain circumstances torture can be justified torture is justifiable if lives of innocent people are in risk or if an entire nation is in danger.
Can the use of torture ever be justified essay today world the in practice banned unequivocally most the perhaps is torture and states united the that claims substantiated ghraib abu from photographs recent yet. Once torture is justified in an extreme case, it can be more easily justified for less serious cases it is very dangerous to consider torture morally justifiable in an extreme- case, for if authorities use torture once and it works, it may be easy for them to become addicted- to its use. Torture can not only be psychologically but mentally painful before the enlightenment, it was perfectly legal to torture individuals but nowadays, it is illegal to torture anyone under any circumstances. A persuasive essay is a form of academic writing that is built around a central argument these essays are sometimes called argumentative essays because of this in this category of composition, the writer aims to persuade the reader to accept his or her.
Ethical arguments have arisen regarding torture, and its debated value to societydespite worldwide condemnation and the existence of treaty provisions that forbid it, some countries still use it the ethical assertion that torture is a tool is at question. Published: mon, 15 may 2017 in advancing into this essay, i shall discuss the history of prohibition of torture, the utilitarian approach to torture which would include arguments and debates in favour of justification of torture by taking account of the ticking bomb hypothetical, a case study of guantanamo bay and the result of torturing terrorist suspects in recent times. Is torture ever acceptable essay is torture ever acceptable essay 856 words 4 pages can torture ever be justified 1596 words | 6 pages can torture, the infliction of intolerable pain to extract potentially life-saving information from war criminals, ever be justified what if this torture or activity is sanctioned or ordered by those. However, some theorists have argued that although torture can in some extreme emergencies be morally justified, nevertheless, torture ought never to be legalised or otherwise institutionalised this position was originally advanced by machan (1990) before being argued in more detail by miller (2005) and (2009), and later by mcmahan (2008.